### *Education on the Horizon: Teaching and Learning with Technology* ## Week 3: Multimedia Learning === #### Dr. Yizhen (Eejain) Huang ###### Department Erziehungswissenschaft, University of Potsdam --- ### What is media? - Media (singular: medium) are tools used to store and deliver information or data - Multimedia are communications that incorporate multiple forms of information content and processing ![](/media/media.jpg) --- ### Medium is like the *vehicle* of information. --- ### You can convey similar content with different media ![](/media/different-transportation.png) --- ### What is multimedia learning - Present the material using various media types that are intended to foster learning. - Types of media: text, audio, static graphic (photos, drawings, maps, charts, figures), dynamic graphic (video, animation), or any other vehicle of information --- ### How to design a course with multimedia elements? > I wonder, how do I decide which medium will be the most fitting one, for the topic as well as for my students? --- ### General rule of thumbs...👍 --- #### 1.The multimedia element needs to have _representational_, not _decorational_, purpose --- - Decorational: the primary instructional function of the element is to intrigue/motivate the learner - Representational: the topic to be learned is explicitly depicted in the multi-media element <!-- [^1]: Höffler, T. N., & Leutner, D. (2007). Instructional animation versus static pictures: A meta-analysis. *Learning and Instruction, 17*, 722–738. --> --- ### Example: Bad Clipart ![](/media/badpres.jpg) --- #### 2. Inclusion of multiple sensory modalities are usually helpful, given that they are _meaningfully_ associated - Storage of information is like a web - More associations = better remembering --- ### Example - When using visuals to teach language, do you really want to teach the visual details? - Using visuals to teach English alphabet? - What about Chinese characters? --- <style> .multicol{ display: flex; } .col_l{ flex: 4; } .col_r{ flex: 4; } </style> <div class="multicol"> <div class="col_l"> <img src="/media/engalphabet.jpeg" > </div> <div class="col_r"> <section> <img src="/media/cnalphabet.jpg" > </section> </div> </div> <!-- [^1]: Schüler, A., Scheiter, K., & van Genuchten, E. (2011). The role of working memory in multimedia instruction: Is working memory working during learning from text and pictures? *Educational Psychology Review, 23*, 389–411. --> --- ### 3. Coherence principle: Remove _unessential_ elements from instructional material --- ### Example: Which one do you choose? - 2 minutes of animated narration introducing ocean waves - the narration plus video clips showing sensational tsunami storms - the narration plus formulas and numerical computations --- ### 4. Temporal/spatial contiguity principle - When both verbal explanation and graphic representation are necessary for learning, present both simultaneously --- ### Example: Which one do you choose? - written text and figure on the same page - written text and figure on different pages <!-- --- --> <!-- ## Some hands-on examples --> <!-- - Let's analyze together: --> <!-- - What kind of multimeida elements are included? --> <!-- - Have they been used properly or not? --> <!-- - Examples --> <!-- + [Support Net](https://www.open.edu/openlearn/health-sports-psychology/mental-health/support-net-can-you-help-someone-need) --> <!-- + [PhotoFit Me](https://www.open.edu/openlearn/body-mind/photofit-me) --> <!-- + [Finding the Truth](https://www.open.edu/openlearn/people-politics-law/the-law/criminology/finding-the-truth) --> <!-- + [Museum of the Dead](https://www.open.edu/openlearn/nature-environment/natural-history/museum-the-dead) --> --- ## Bonus: choose single medium --- ### Sometimes visuals are better than words? --- ### Example 1. How would you explain how a *smart phone* works? --- ![](/media/cellphone.png) --- ### Example 2. How do you decide what to wear? --- ![](/media/decisiontree2.png) --- ### Visual over words - When the concept is abstract and hard to visualize in the mind. - When the logic is not linear. - [example in presentation slides design](https://prezi.com/p/7upyb8nulbzs/ux-design-tips-for-product-managers/?click_source=logged_element&element_type=prezi_card&element_text=7upyb8nulbzs) <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Audio over visual? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Audio carries unique information -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + Example: [Hearning range test (6:25-10:00)](https://www.20k.org/episodes/hearingloss ) -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### What about personal preferences for media types? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Is the "learning style" theory true? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Claims of the learning style theory: -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + Each person has a preferred way of receiving new information: visual, auditory, kinesthetic -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + When learning something new, student will learn better when the instruction matches their preferred media types -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + Are these claims true? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Example of instruction according to learning style theory -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - When learning addition... -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Visual learner: view grouping of objects -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Auditory learner: listen to sets of rhythms -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Kinesthetic learner: arrange objects into groups -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### What's wrong with this approach? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - No matter what's the input module, most of the information are encoded semantically (as meaning) -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Everyone can benefit from various representations of the same content -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Recap -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Multimedia learning: present the material using various media types that are intended to foster learning. -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Media types can include text, audio, static graphic (photos, drawings, maps, charts, figures), dynamic graphic (video, animation), or any other vehicles of information (we experience the world through different senses) -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Thank you for the active discussion in Discord! Let's address some of the questions 😁 -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- > It wasn't clear to me before that reading a text on an iPad...is not multi media learning -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- > -- Luisa -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Difference between "environment" and "medium" -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - The tablet is an learning *environment* -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - You can either present single- or multi-*media* content in this environment -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + a "book behind glass" or a "interactive, media-rich" environment -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### Learning style theory: pros and cons -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Claims of the learning style theory: -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + Each person has a preferred way of receiving new information: visual, auditory, kinesthetic (True) -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + When learning something new, student will learn better when the instruction matches their preferred media types (False) -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Students do have preferences, but that don't translate directly to performance, because their knowledge/skill is often not tested directly from these sensory modalities -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- + e.g., Students learn about additon by hearing a song vs. students learn about harmonious patteren by hearing a song, which makes more sense? -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- > I still don't really understand why the teacher's voice is not a medium. I don't see a big difference between a voice and an audio recording. -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- > -- Jenny/ErikM -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- f -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- --- -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- ### xx learning ≠ learning through xx -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Auditory learning and learning through audio is different, same for visual leanring and learning through visual -\-> --> <!-- <\!-- - Whether you are really trying to teach (and test) some information from this particular sensory modality, or simply use it as a vehicle. -\-> --> --- ### But are visuals also relevant for PE? > In PE lessons it might be more difficult (to use audio/visual), because to me movement is always something you have to experience in order to learn and improve it. <!-- <\!-- > -- Luisa -\-> --> --- - For acquiring procedural-motor knowledge, dynamic imagery is actually quite powerful (learning by watching) - But need to consider different visual perspectives --- ### Examples about visual perspectives - External is better internal imagery when learning about how to position different body parts: [Gymnastics](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JueHTIusqzI) - Internal is better than external imagery when learning about how to position body in relation to the environment: [Skiing](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4tsX20dPX0)